A relationship that’s focused on your needs.

Your family, your business and your possessions are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We have the experience to navigate the unique risks you face, serving as your insurance advisor in Shelbyville, Bethany, Effingham, Pana, Vandalia, Sullivan, Mattoon, Moweaqua, Assumption, Hillsboro, Charleston, Shelby County, Effingham County, Coles County, Moultrie County, Fayette County, Central Illinois and Southern Illinois.

Risks are unique for each consumer and business

We utilize our RiskLock process to:
  • Identify Exposures and Risk Issues
  • Develop Strategies to Mitigate Risk
  • Implement Programs to Protect Assets
  • Reduce Insurance Costs
  • Monitor the Program Results

Our trusted advisors protect your personal assets, commercial operations and valued employees.

Partner Beyond INsurance

Member of the

Beyond Insurance Global Network

What sets us apart

Choice

Our prominent relationships with reputable insurance carriers will allow you the power of choice.

Expertise

Our advisors have years of experience in the identification and mitigation of risk and serve as your advocate in protecting your assets.

Service

Our team has a passion for delivering exceptional service to exceed our clients’ expectations.

How We Came To Be Shelbyville Insurance Services:

1978

Roy Shuff purchased the Earl Riley Agency.

1980

Harry Russell joined as partner of the Earl Riley Agency.

1981

Richard “Dutch” Firnhaber joined as a partner of the Earl Riley Agency and all three partners purchased the Davis Agency and changed the name to the Riley-Davis Agency.

1984

Randy Biehler joined the Riley-Davis Agency, which was re-named Shelbyville Insurance Services.

1986

Gary Arthur joined the agency

1986

Randy Biehler became a partner and all the partners purchased the Crowder Agency in Bethany.

1992

Cathy Biddlecombe joined

1993

Our relationship with the Dansig began.

2006

Roy and Harry retired and Danny Sr. and Darren Reynolds became co-owners.

2012

Dutch retired and Dan Jr. joined the agency.

2013

Derek Hayden joined the agency.

2013

Amy Myers joined the agency.

2016

Joined Beyond Insurance Global Network

2016

Keith Probst joined the agency.

2016

Kris Gambrill joined the agency.

2018

Cristy Pullen joined the agency.

Our Commitment

Industry-Leading Technology, Investment and Ongoing Preparation for the Future
Customized, Flexible and Comprehensive Services
Cost-Effective Proven Solutions
Personal and Responsive Customer Service
Long-Standing Client Relationships