Skip to main content

Insurance agency in Shelbyville and Bethany, Illinois.

Specializing in Home Insurance, Auto InsuranceCommercial Insurance and Employee Benefits throughout Central and Southern Illinois.
Learn MoreRiskLock


Insurance solutions tailored to fit your unique lifestyle.


Thorough coverage for today’s business.

Employee Benefits

Benefits programs that support employees.


Risk management for unique exposures.

Client Self Service

Your Trusted Advisor in Shelbyville and Bethany, Illinois.

Shelbyville Insurance Services combines the knowledge of insurance and risk management with proven expertise in individual and employee benefits to provide a thorough approach to all of your insurance and benefit needs. Since 1978, we have been providing insurance and benefits solutions for individuals and businesses in Shelbyville and the surrounding communities.

  Our Mission

Our mission is to be the advisor of choice for our clients, the employer of choice for our team members and a contributing partner to the communities we serve.

Our Specialties

SIS has provided a positive impact on our budgetary resources, as utilizing a third party for these services would be cost prohibitive. We recommend SIS and their (RiskLock) process to any organization.

Jeff Johnson, Mayor-City of Shelbyville

Derek Hayden is an excellent agent. Knowledgeable and attentive.

Julie Ruscin-Beer

There’s more to insurance than the price of the policy

Explore our interactive graphics and learn about your unique risks and the related insurance solutions.

Explore Commercial Graphics

Explore Personal Graphics

Explore Benefits Graphics